Comments on: Should Failing Students Be Held Back? https://teach4theheart.com/should-failing-students-be-held-back/ support & community for Christian teachers Tue, 19 Jan 2021 07:15:50 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.1.4 By: Kelly https://teach4theheart.com/should-failing-students-be-held-back/#comments/11371 Tue, 17 May 2016 04:49:57 +0000 https://teach4theheart.com/?p=3100#comment-11371 Touchy subject. In 28 years I’ve retained 2 kiddos. One was a medical reason. The other just plain worked out well. Being a 4th grade teacher it’s very hard to retain, but what do we do with kiddos who aren’t to standard, don’t have help at home, and are so far behind? I pray for these kiddos who don’t fit the Light’s Retention Scale which is what my school uses. I wish we could retain more kids.

]]>
By: Teri Young https://teach4theheart.com/should-failing-students-be-held-back/#comments/1854 Thu, 28 May 2015 00:51:30 +0000 https://teach4theheart.com/?p=3100#comment-1854 I agree it depends on the student, but I think there is a larger issue to consider here.

If we don not teach children how to fail AND recover from failure, are we doing the world any good? Success is not guaranteed. If I do not perform my job to my boss’s specifications, should I expect a promotion? Life is not a ‘do your time and get ahead’ game. It is a ‘work hard, learn all you can, perform as best you can, and hope to break even’ reality.

Case 1: A mother came to me furious because her secon grade son got a “C” on his special education math test. (He could not count ten objects.) Her complaint, “How is this supposed to encourage him to do better?” Grades are encouragement?!?

Case 2: A teenager who was developmentally seven years old graduated ‘with honors’ from special education. She couldn’t tell you what state she lived in, but she told me she was going to be a doctor.
She went into deep depression for months when she found out she could not get into community college.

Let’s give education a reality check. Not everyone CAN be president when they grow up. Some NEED to work at Walmart as greeters. Even ‘normal’ children will not excel in all subjects. They should not be taught that they are failures if they are not good at one thing. They should be taught to look at their strengths and find goals that make them happy. It should be our job as educators to help them find their niche, and learn to live as best they can.

Case 3: A young couple worked at the resource center folding inserts for packages. They had a daily contest to see who could fold the most, and the winner got to pick the television program that night. They knew their limits, but reached for their goals with a joyful mentality. That, to me, is success.

]]>
By: Teri Young https://teach4theheart.com/should-failing-students-be-held-back/#comments/1853 Thu, 28 May 2015 00:50:21 +0000 https://teach4theheart.com/?p=3100#comment-1853 I agree it depends on the student, but I think there is a larger issue to consider here.

If we don not teach children how to fail AND recover from failure, are we doing the world any good? Success is not guaranteed. If I do not perform my job to my boss’s specifications, should I expect a promotion? Life is not a ‘do your time and get ahead’ game. It is a ‘work hard, learn all you can, perform as best you can, and hope to break even’ reality.

Case 1: A mother came to me furious because her secon grade son got a “C” on his special education math test. (He could not count ten objects.) Her complaint, “How is this supposed to encourage him to do better?” Grades are encouragement?!?

Case 2: A teenager who was developmentally seven years old graduated ‘with honors’ from special education. She couldn’t tell you what state she lived in, but she told me she was going to be a doctor.
She went into deep depression for months when she found out she could not get into community college.

Let’s give education a reality check. Not everyone CAN be president when they grow up. Some NEED to work at Walmart as greeters. Even ‘normal’ children will not excel in all subjects. They should not be taught that they are failures if they are not good at one thing. They should be taught to look at their strengths and find goals that make them happy. It should be our job as educators to help them find their niche, and learn to live as best they can.

Case 3: A young couple worked at the resource center folding inserts for packages. They had a daily contest to see who could fold the most, and the winner got to pick the television program that night. They knew their limits, but reached for their goals with a joyful mentality. That, to me, is success.

]]>
By: F p https://teach4theheart.com/should-failing-students-be-held-back/#comments/1850 Sat, 23 May 2015 11:26:53 +0000 https://teach4theheart.com/?p=3100#comment-1850 In my school we are not really allowed to give Fs…teachers get hauled into the principals office if a D or F is on a kid’s progress report or report card and made to explain why. Teachers are basically blamed for it. Grades mean nothing where I am, which unfortunately the kids know. 🙁

]]>
By: Maria Ellis https://teach4theheart.com/should-failing-students-be-held-back/#comments/1848 Tue, 19 May 2015 10:59:00 +0000 https://teach4theheart.com/?p=3100#comment-1848 I think it truly depends on the student… I have one student right now that does not have a clue how to do most of the 6th grade math we just spent a year working on… so I think repeating would help him. I have another student that is super bright and can learn quickly but he played a lot this year and it caused him to fail. I know he could learn the material next year in 7th easily and do well… putting him back for the sake of a punishment… I am not sure that is in his best interest.

]]>
By: Maria Ellis https://teach4theheart.com/should-failing-students-be-held-back/#comments/1847 Mon, 18 May 2015 20:28:44 +0000 https://teach4theheart.com/?p=3100#comment-1847 I think it truly depends on the student… I have one student right now that does not have a clue how to do most of the 6th grade math we just spent a year working on… so I think repeating would help him. I have another student that is super bright and can learn quickly but he played a lot this year and it caused him to fail. I know he could learn the material next year in 7th easily and do well… putting him back for the sake of a punishment… I am not sure that is in his best interest.

]]>